MBI Logo

Workshop 5: Uncertainty in Ecological Analysis (April 3-6, 2006)

Organizers: Kate Calder, Jim Clark, Noel Cressie, Jay Ver Hoef, and Chris Wikle

The field of ecology is becoming increasingly aware of the importance of accurately accounting for multiple sources of uncertainty when modeling ecological phenomena and making forecasts. This development is motivated in part by the desire to provide an accurate picture of the state of knowledge of ecosystems and to be able to better assess the quality of predictions of local and global change. However, accounting for various sources of uncertainty is by no means a simple task. Ecological data are almost always observed incompletely with large and unknown amounts of measurement error or data uncertainty, and often the expense of data collection prohibits collecting as much data as might be desirable. In addition, most ecological phenomena of interest can only be studied by combining various sources of data; aligning these data properly presents interesting statistical challenges. While data plays a large role in most ecological analyses, incorporating scientific knowledge into the analyses through substantive modeling of ecological processes is essential. Often such theoretical contributions are based on competing scientific theories and simplifications of reality. This results in an additional source of uncertainty termed model or process uncertainty. Finally, substantive models must acknowledge parameter uncertainty. For example, more realistic descriptions of ecosystems might allow parameters to vary over space and time.

The aim of this workshop is to present a thorough investigation and discussion of these various sources of uncertainty that typically play a role in ecological analyses and of the statistical techniques that enable proper inferences and predictions to be made in light of these uncertainties. These concepts will be illustrated using new data sources and sophisticated modeling tools developed for studying a diverse collection of ecological phenomena. In addition, there will be a discussion of strategies for reducing some of the sources of uncertainty including improved design of monitoring networks. This discussion will promote increased communication between the theoretical and empirical communities as to prioritizing data collection efforts. One of the largest communities to use these methods for important decision-making is state and federal governments, and they will be involved in the workshop as well. In summary, this workshop will provide an opportunity for the ecological science community to interact with the statistical and abstract-modeling communities and will promote novel, interdisciplinary research developments on complex models, inference, and design in the face of various sources of uncertainty.

Schedule


Each talk was followed by discussion.
Monday, April 3
8:45-9:00am Opening Remarks: Avner Friedman and Noel Cressie (Chair)
9:00-10:00am Noel Cressie: Uncertainty in Ecological Analysis: Introduction
Timothy Gregoire (Chair)
10:00-10:30am Coffee break
10:30-12:00pm Byron Morgan and Mark Berliner: Methodology Overview
Anthony Olsen (Chair)
12:00-1:30pm Lunch break
1:30-2:15pm Jay Ver Hoef: Ecological Study: Introduction
Rolf Turner (Chair)
2:15-3:00pm Seven group meetings with leaders: Steve Buckland, Alan Hastings, Jennifer Hoeting, B. Manly, Lance Waller, Linda Young, and Dale Zimmerman
Rolf Turner (Chair)
3:00-3:30pm Coffee break
3:30-5:00pm Alan Gelfand and Jay Breidt: Modeling in the Presence of Uncertainty
Jennifer Hoeting and Lance Waller (Discussion)
Steve Rathbun (Chair)
5:00-8:00pm Reception
Tuesday, April 4
8:45-10:15am Ottar Bjornstad, Brian Dennis, and Steve Buckland: Population Dynamics
Michael Lavine and Mark Maunder (Discussion)
Alan Hastings (Chair)
10:15-10:45am Coffee break
10:45-11:30am Shannon La Deau, Devin Johnson, and Jarrett Barber: New researchers
Jarrett Barber (Chair)
11:30-12:30pm Group meetings
12:30-1:30pm Lunch break
1:30-3:00pm William Link, Andy Royle, and Robert Dorazio: Abundance Estimation
Ken Burnham and Chong He (Discussion)
Mark Bravington (Chair)
3:00-3:30pm Coffee break
3:30-4:30pm Jim Clark: Keynote Address
Catherine Calder (Chair)
4:30-5:00pm Coffee break
6:00-8:30pm SSES Sponsored Reception (Schiermeier Olentangy River Wetland Research Park)
Opening remarks: Rick Freeman, Dean of MAPS
Wednesday, April 5
8:45-10:15am Marie-Josee Fortin and Chris Wikle: Spatial Patterns and Processes
Subhash Lele and Philip Dixon (Discussion)
Pascal Monestiez (Chair)
10:15-10:45am Coffee break
10:45-11:30am Mevin Hooten, Kiona Ogle, Bret Elderd: New Researchers
Alexandra Schmidt (Chair)
11:30-12:00pm Group meetings
12:00-1:30pm Lunch break
1:30-3:00pm Aaron Ellison, Brian Beckage, and Rachel Fewster: Community Ecology
Anthony Ives and D. Estep (Discussion)
Eric Parent (Chair)
3:00-3:30pm Coffee break
3:30-5:00pm Gabriel Katul, and Steve Wofsy: Complexity in Ecosystem Analysis
Doug Nychka and Donald De Angelis (Discussion)
Peter Curtis (Chair)
6:00-7:00pm Cash bar (Holiday Inn)
7:00-9:00pm Workshop Dinner/ Group Presentations (Holiday Inn)
Thursday, April 6
8:45-10:15am Panel discussion: Alan Gelfand, Mark Kaiser, Michael Lavine, Subhash Lele, B. Manly, and Jay Ver Hoef
Noel Cressie (Moderator)
10:15-10:45am Coffee break
10:45-11:45am Mark Mangel: Uncertainty in Ecological Analysis: A Retrospective
Doug Johnson (Chair)
12:00-1:30pm Lunch/Closing Reception (Holiday Inn)